Clarifying the pope’s comments about contraception
Scots Catholic - Calling Scotland's 841,000 Catholics to unite as one voice
Scots Catholic Blog

Clarifying the pope’s comments about contraception

Another in-flight interview, yet another media frenzy.  It seems that every time Pope Francis takes to the skies there is more and more controversy, particularly from those who seem to have a strange interest in changing Church teaching.


This time one of the more interesting comments from the Holy Father was on the subject of contraception.  The pope was asked a question about the Zika virus and whether abortion [as the lesser of two evils] or avoiding pregnancy would be acceptable courses of action for women to take.  In response the pope stated that “Abortion is not the lesser of two evils. It is a crime. It is to throw someone out in order to save another. That’s what the Mafia does. It is a crime, an absolute evil.”  So that is pretty clear.


But it’s what he then went on to say that may be a cause for concern for some.  He said: “Paul VI, a great man, in a difficult situation in Africa, permitted nuns to use contraceptives in cases of rape.”  He added later: “avoiding pregnancy is not an absolute evil. In certain cases, as in this one, or in the one I mentioned of Blessed Paul VI, it was clear.”  Francis is, of course, referring to Pope Paul VI, one of the greatest and most outspoken proponents of Catholic teaching on sexuality.  So is the pope suggesting that the use of contraceptives is okay? 


In order to tackle this question it is perhaps best to give due consideration to Church teaching on the matter.  Firstly, by referring to ‘avoiding pregnancy not being an absolute evil’ the pope isn’t necessarily referring to contraception.  For some time the Church has accepted the use of natural family planning by married couples.  This is where a couple recognise their own pattern of fertility and use this knowledge to plan a family in order to give them the opportunity to raise their children in the best environment possible.  Natural family planning is not contrary to the teaching of the Church in the same way as contraception because, unlike contraception, natural family planning is still open to new life during each sexual encounter and the couple also give themselves completely to the other.  With contraception there is a clear barrier between the man and woman which prevents one giving him or herself completely to the other and there is also a distinct lack of openness to new life.          


As Catholics we are called to give ourselves completely to the other in marriage.  And as sexual union is part of our marriage then we must be prepared to give ourselves completely to the other each time we embrace that act. We have to be a gift to our spouse.  Totally and unconditionally.  If we do not do this i.e. by using contraception, then we are acting contrary to Church teaching.  This is why contraception is immoral. 


So what about the nuns in Africa?  In these cases there would have been no voluntarily act of self-giving on the part of the nuns.  The nuns did not desire to participate in this sexual encounter.  As a result the use of birth control in this instance is not viewed as being an immoral barrier between the self-giving love of one spouse to another with the accompanying openness to new life.  Rather it is seen as an act of self-defence on the part of someone upon whom a criminal act is being perpetrated.  Further, the sexual encounter in this case was not within the realm of marriage i.e. it was not conjugal.  Therefore, it actually falls outwith Church teaching on the issue (an issue tackled by Jimmy Akin here).  This, I expect, is why Pope Paul VI sanctioned their use in these circumstances.


This, of course, is entirely different from the situation surrounding the Zika virus.  Here we are talking about women who are voluntarily engaging in sexual relations but who are using contraceptives to prevent new life.  This is clearly immoral and contrary to Church teaching.  These women do, however, have recourse to natural family planning, which is very much in accordance with the Church and is not immoral.


Let’s be clear, Church teaching on contraception is not about to change. 


1 Comment to Clarifying the pope’s comments about contraception:

Comments RSS
Elaine on 19 February 2016 12:29
I appreciate your explanation for a very difficult issue...Children are a gift from God; as we read in Scripture; and spouses who love God entrust Him with their fertility.
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Website:
Comment:
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment
RSS Follow

Recent Posts

Scots support reduced abortion time limits and statutory waiting period
Catholic Bishops call for faithful to reflect on beauth and goodness of Church teaching ahead of General Election
With Christianity dying out in Europe we need the family more than ever
Cadbury, don't let the bullies win
Peaceful and prayerful: 40 Days for Life returns to Scotland this Lent

Categories

Abortion
Abortion, pro-life
Abstinence
Abuse
Adoption
Adultery
Agnosticism
Amoris Laetitia
Angels
Angelus
Annunciation
Apologetics
Art
Ascension
AsceSolemnitynsion
Assisted Dying
Assisted Suicide
Asylum
Atheism
Baptism
Beatitudes
Bible
Bishop
Buddhism
Canon Law
Capital Punishment
Catechism
Catholic
Catholic Education
Cerebral Palsy
Charity
Chastity
Children
Christian
Christian Unity
Christianity
Christmas
Church
Church Doctors
Commandments
Confession
Confirmation
Consecration
Contraception
Creation
Crime
Crucifixion
Death
Devil
Devotion
Disability
Divination
Division
Divorce
Down's Syndrome
Dwelling on the Word of God
Easter
Ecumenism
Edinburgh
Education
Encyclical
EU
Eucharist
Eugenics
Europe
European Parliament
European Union
Euthanasia
Evangelii Gaudium
Evangelisation
Events
Evil
Evolution
Excommunication
Exorcism
Exorcist
Facebook
Faith
Family
Fatherhood
Feast Days
Film
Football
Forgiveness
Gender
Gendercide
General Audience
General Election
Genocide
Glasgow
God
Gospel
Gospel Reflection
Gossip
Handing on the Faith
Health
Heaven
Hell
Holy Communion
Holy Spirit
Homosexuality
Idolatry
Incest
Infanticide
Internet
Islam
Jesus
Journalism
Joy
Judaism
Laudato Si
Law
Learn the Catholic Faith
Lent
Life
Love
Magisterium
Marriage
Martyrdom
Mary
Mass
Media
Medical Research
Mercy
Messi
Miracle
Missions
Money
Mother of God
Motu Proprio
Nativity
Natural Family Planning
News
Nightfever
Our Lady
Papacy
Parish
Passion
Peace
Persecution
Politics
Pope Benedict XVI
Pope Francis
Pornography
Poverty
Prayer
Precepts
Priesthood
Pro-Choice
Pro-Life
Protestantism
Purgatory
Radio
Reconciliation
Refugee
Relativism
Religion
Rome
Ronaldo
Rosary
Sacrament
Sacrifice
Safeguarding
Saints
Salvation
Same Sex Marriage
Satan
Science
Scotland
Scottish Government
Scottish Parliament
Scripture
Sectarianism
Secularism
Sex
Sin
Soccer
Social Media
Solemnity
Sport
Stations of the Cross
Suffering
Suicide
Survey
Synod
Technology
Television
Tradition
Transgender
Trinity
Truth
Twitter
UK Parliament
UN
United Kingdom
United States
Unity
Vatican
Via Crucis
Virgin Mary
Vocations
War
Way of the Cross
Women
Word of God
World Cup
World Youth Day
Year of Faith
Youth

Archives

May 2017
April 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
September 2016
August 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013

powered by

Website Builder provided by  Vistaprint